Create an Automatic Free Shipping Discount on the Shopify

Do you hold back from offering free shipping because it seems too expensive? Research shows that 70% of U.S. online shoppers say free shipping is the main reason they buy online.

For Shopify store owners, setting up automatic free shipping can be a real turning point. It removes the guesswork for shoppers and keeps them from bouncing at checkout.

In this guide, you will understand how to set up an automatic free shipping discount on Shopify. You’ll also learn how to activate free shipping with codes, test it for your key locations and products, and match your store setup to your goals. By the end, you’ll have a smooth, easy approach that avoids customer frustration and helps keep more sales.

Key Takeaways

• Clear and fair return policies build customer trust and encourage repeat purchases.
• Personalized return experiences can turn refunds into future sales opportunities.
• Effective upselling during returns increases average order value without aggressive tactics.
• Avoiding common return process mistakes improves efficiency and customer satisfaction.
• Data from returns helps refine inventory management and product quality.

Why You May Need to Offer Free Shipping Discounts?

Free shipping has become more than a perk; it’s now an expectation. According to Statista (May, 2025), 39% of U.S. customers abandon their carts due to extra delivery costs, even if the product price feels right. For Shopify store owners, ignoring this demand could mean missing out on consistent sales and loyal customers.

Here are some key reasons why this strategy can work for your business:

1. Reduce Cart Abandonment

High shipping costs are one of the biggest reasons shoppers quit before paying. By offering free shipping, you remove a major conversion barrier.

This simple change can keep more customers in the checkout flow, directly promoting your order completion rates without changing your product prices.

2. Increase Average Order Value (AOV)

When shoppers know they can access free shipping by spending a specific amount, they often add more to their carts. In fact, for free shipping, people are willing to spend $40 on average.

This behaviour helps you boost sales per customer, giving you more revenue per transaction while keeping your fulfillment costs predictable.

Must Read: Understanding the e-Commerce Order Management System

3. Stay Competitive in the Market

Your competitors might already offer free shipping. If you don’t, customers may choose them over you, even if your products are better. A free shipping offer can be the deciding factor that keeps customers from leaving for other stores.

4. Improves Customer Satisfaction Scores

Free shipping creates a sense of added value, which can improve post-purchase satisfaction. Happy customers are more likely to leave positive reviews, recommend your store, and respond to future promotions, improving both your reputation and organic growth.

5. Increases Conversion Rates on Promotions

Pairing free shipping with seasonal or limited-time offers can make campaigns far more appealing. This combination creates urgency and value, motivating shoppers to act quickly. It’s an easy way to strengthen marketing efforts without heavily discounting your products.

Free shipping discounts can turn hesitant shoppers into paying customers while improving your store’s long-term performance. Understanding why they work sets the stage for learning how to set them up efficiently with an automatic system in Shopify.

How to Create an Automatic Free Shipping Discount?

Do you want to offer free shipping to your customers without the hassle of entering a code? Shopify’s automatic discount feature can help. Setting this up ensures a smooth checkout process and increases the chances that customers complete their purchase. The process is quick, straightforward, and can be managed directly from your mobile app.

Here’s a step-by-step guide to create an automatic free shipping discount on the Shopify app:

1. In the Shopify app, tap the three horizontal bars, then select Discounts.
2. Tap the + button to create a new discount.
3. From the discount type menu, select Free shipping.
4. Under Method, choose Automatic discount.
5. Enter a name in the Title text field; it will appear in the cart and checkout.
6. In the Countries section, keep All countries selected or choose specific ones you want the discount to apply to.
   
   • To exclude free shipping for high shipping rates, check Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount and enter the limit.
7. (Optional) In Availability, select Also offer on Point of Sale (POS Pro locations only) if needed.
8. In Minimum purchase requirements, choose between a purchase amount or the quantity of items.
9. In Eligibility, choose who can use the discount:
   
   • All customers
   • Specific customers (then select them)
   • Specific customer segments (then select the segment)
10. (Optional) In Combinations, select the discount codes that customers can combine with other discounts. Briefly check the automatic free shipping discount classes to be eligible to combine.
11. Under Active dates, set a start date and time.
    
    • To add an end date, check Set end date and choose the date.
    • For a one-day offer, use the same date for start and end.
12. Review the setup in the Summary section.
13. Tap Save discount

Once saved, your automatic free shipping discount will apply evenly to eligible orders. This small setup can have a big impact on reducing abandoned carts and improving conversions, especially when paired with other shipping incentives. Now, let’s see how you can create discount codes for free shipping.

How to Create a Free Shipping Discount Code?

Sometimes you want customers to enter a code to get free shipping. This method works well for special promotions, email campaigns, or exclusive offers. Shopify makes it simple to create a discount code that offers free shipping at checkout.

Here’s how to set it up from your Shopify admin:

1. In your Shopify admin, go to Discounts.
2. Click Create discount.
3. From the discount type menu, select Free shipping.
4. Under Method, choose Discount code.
5. In the Discount code field, type a code name or click Generate code.
6. In Countries, keep All countries selected or pick specific ones that you want the discount to apply to.
   
   • To exclude high-cost shipping, check Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount and enter the limit.
7. (Optional) If your store offers subscriptions, choose whether the discount applies to One-time purchase, Subscription, or Both.
8. (Optional) Again, you can limit shipping by checking Exclude shipping rates over a certain amount and entering a value.
9. (Optional) Under Minimum requirements, select either a purchase amount or item quantity and enter the required value.
10. In Eligibility, choose who can use the discount:
    
    • All customers
    • Specific customers (then select them)
    • Specific customer segments (then select the segment)
11. By default, usage is unlimited. In Usage limits, you can:
    
    • Limit total uses (e.g., 200 times)
    • Limit to one per customer (tracked by email or phone)
12. In Combinations, select the discount codes that can be clubbed under one category.
13. In Active dates, set the start date and time.
    
    • To set an end date, check Set end date and choose the date.
    • For a single-day offer, use the same date for start and end.
14. Click Save when finished.

Once active, your free shipping code can enhance engagement during sales, holiday events, or exclusive drops, especially when paired with targeted marketing. But, there might be specific challenges that could come your way, so let’s see how you can tackle them next. 

Common Mistakes When Offering Automatic Free Shipping Discounts

Free shipping can be a powerful sales tool, but it can also backfire if implemented poorly. Many Shopify store owners set up discounts without considering the costs, the customer experience, or the long-term brand impact. These oversights can lead to reduced profit margins and frustrated shoppers.

Let’s look at some common mistakes you should avoid when creating free shipping discounts.

1. Setting Unrealistic Minimum Order Values

Some store owners set the minimum spend too high, thinking it will boost order values. Instead, it can discourage buyers from completing their purchase. Analyze your average order value (AOV) before setting thresholds. Aim for a balance where customers see the target as achievable, yet high enough to increase revenue without hurting margins.

2. Ignoring Profit Margins

Offering free shipping without calculating fulfilment costs can eat into profits. Small and medium-sized stores often overlook packaging, carrier fees, and handling costs. Always run the numbers before launching a discount. Consider using a slightly higher product price or increasing order value thresholds to absorb these costs without affecting profitability.

3. Applying Free Shipping to All Products

Not all products should qualify for free shipping, especially bulky, heavy, or low-margin items. If you apply the offer storewide, you risk losing money on these orders. Instead, limit free shipping to specific categories or set conditions that encourage customers to purchase higher-margin items along with heavier ones.

Must Read: Tips to Minimize Shipping Costs for Small Businesses

4. Making It Hard to Understand

If customers have to hunt through pages to figure out the free shipping rules, they may abandon their cart. Confusing terms, hidden fees, or unclear thresholds reduce trust. Display your offer clearly on the homepage, product pages, and checkout. Simplicity is essential; customers should know instantly what qualifies.

5. Forgetting to Test and Adjust

A free shipping strategy that works today may not be effective six months later. Market conditions, shipping costs, and customer habits change. Avoid the “set it and forget it” trap. Review analytics regularly, track conversion rates, and adjust your free shipping rules based on what’s driving results.

Overlooking these common pitfalls can undermine the benefits of your free shipping offer, turning a valuable incentive into a costly misstep. By recognizing and addressing them early, you can protect your margins and keep customers happy. 

Platforms like Return Prime can further enhance your post-purchase experience, ensuring shoppers return with confidence.

How Return Prime Can Help Simplify Returns and Exchanges?

Return Prime, is a return management platform designed for Shopify brands that want to make returns, exchanges, and refunds simple for both their team and their customers. It is trusted by hundreds of stores and holds a 4.9/5 rating on the Shopify App Store. Whether you’re a growing D2C label or an established online retailer, it helps you handle post-purchase returns without chaos or delays.

A great example is Bummer, a fast-growing D2C innerwear brand.

Before using Return Prime, Bummer struggled with manual return handling, slow processing times, and frustrated customers waiting for updates.

After partnering with Return Prime, Bummer:

• Reduced their return processing time by 87.5% even with 2–3x more orders.
• They even narrowed their return requests by 74%, thanks to smart exchange workflows.

For Bummer, Return Prime didn’t just simplify returns; it created a scalable, customer-friendly system that supported their rapid growth.

Here are some of the salient features of Return Prime:

• Centralized Return Management

Manage all your return, exchange, and refund requests from one place. The dashboard gives you real-time updates, so you can track every request without digging through emails or spreadsheets. It saves time and reduces the risk of missing or delaying a customer request.

• Turn returns into exchanges with Wonder Smart Exchange

Return Prime allows customers to choose an exchange instead of a refund, helping you retain revenue. The system automatically updates inventory, processes the exchange, and notifies the customer, removing the need for manual intervention. It keeps the process smooth for both you and your customers.

• Upsell with Wonder Revenue Booster

Turn returns into fresh sales opportunities by suggesting relevant products during the return journey. Return Prime’s Wonder Revenue Booster feature helps you recommend items your customers are likely to buy, converting a potential loss into a new order and strengthening long-term loyalty.

• Build custom return and exchange policies

Set up flexible policies that align with your brand’s needs. You can define return windows, exchange conditions, and eligible products. It helps you avoid unnecessary returns while still giving customers a clear, fair, and transparent process that improves trust in your store.

• Send automated notifications

Keep your team and your customers updated through automated email and SMS alerts. Customers know exactly when their return is approved, shipped, or refunded, reducing follow-up queries. For your store, it means less time answering status emails and more time focusing on growth.

• Turn refunds into store credits with Wonder Promotions

Instead of only offering refunds, you can provide store credit or discount vouchers to encourage repeat purchases. This simple option helps you recover lost revenue and improve customer retention without creating friction in the returns process.

• Analytics and ROI Tools

Access Return Prime’s user-friendly ROI calculator to measure the direct financial impact of returns management for your store. It provides quick estimates of how much revenue and cost savings you can achieve by optimizing your return processes, automating exchanges, and utilizing store credits and upsells.

Return Prime is the most affordable option for managing returns, strengthening customer relationships, and improving sales.

Conclusion

For many eCommerce brands, returns are a silent profit drain. Manual processing, inconsistent updates, and poor customer communication often lead to frustration on both sides. Even when customers get their money back, the brand experience can leave a negative impression.

But returns don’t have to be just a cost of doing business. With the right approach, they can strengthen customer trust, simplify operations, and even open up new sales opportunities. A well-managed returns process reduces friction, encourages repeat purchases, and builds loyalty.

Platforms like Return Prime, built for Shopify brands, turn returns, exchanges, and refunds into a hassle-free, revenue-positive process.

 Ready to see how your brand can simplify returns and retain more customers? Book a demo with Return Prime today and make your post-purchase journey a growth driver.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can I set free shipping for specific products only?

Yes, you can target free shipping to select products by using custom shipping profiles or Shopify apps that let you apply shipping rules by product type or collection, so you avoid offering it on heavy or low-margin items and retain control over cost.

2. Will free shipping codes affect my taxes or shipping rates?

Free shipping codes don’t change product pricing or tax settings. Shopify calculates taxes based on your tax settings, while shipping costs adjust separately. Just ensure your tax rules and shipping profiles are correctly set so the code applies only to shipping, not product cost or taxes.

3. Can automatic free shipping work with multiple locations?

Yes, shopify supports multiple locations, and your free shipping discount will apply as long as the order meets the criteria, regardless of location. Just ensure your discount settings and shipping zones include all intended locations. Use apps if you need advanced location-level control.

4. Will free shipping codes stack with other discounts automatically?

Only if you set it up to do so. In the “Combinations” section, you can allow free shipping codes to combine with other discount types. If not enabled, Shopify will treat each discount independently, and only one may apply at checkout.

5. How can I track how well my free shipping offer performs?

Use Shopify’s built-in analytics to track discount usage, conversion rates, and average order value changes. You can also filter for orders tagged with “Free Shipping.” If you want deeper insights, platforms like Return Prime can help link return behaviors with shipping incentives.

‍